Assignment #2 Grading Criteria and Score Sheet  
--name __________________________  IS 483 Autumn 2000/2001

Section

Tally

  Detail

Scoring Points:

Exposition
in 
Paper 		A.
9.0 pts.



1. _____ / 1.0

2. _____ / 1.0

3. _____ /1.0

4. _____ / 1.0

5. _____ / 1.0

6. _____ / 1.0

7. _____ / 1.0

8. _____ / 2.0

 		A. Organizational Analysis 
Analyze the organization and its IS area by advising the reader of the following in the paper:
_1. The organizational mission, goals and strategy 

_2. The mission, goals and strategy of IS 

_3. The IS organizational structure and its rationale including
      org chart - 

_4. The organization of IT operations and rationale: centralized,
       decentralized, distributed or outsourced. 

_5. The velocity of change in IS for past 3 years. 

_6. The IS governance for determining strategies and tactics. 

_7. The IS evaluation and procurement process. 

_ 8. Overall Fit.  
B.
10.0 pts.



1. _____ / 1.25

2. _____ / 1.25

3.1 _____ / 1.0

3.2 _____ / 1.0

3.3 _____ / 1.0 

3.4 _____ / 1.0 

3.5 _____ / 1.0

3.6 _____ / 1.0

4. _____ /   1.5

B. Requirements Analysis (Pre-RFP)

_1. Problem Statement -- 

_2. Current Risks -- 

_3. Alternative Solutions Summary -- 

-- The potential costs --
---3.1-----  up-front costs
---3.2-----  on-going costs
-- The potential benefits  --
----3.3------ short-term
----3.4------ long-term
-- The potential risks --
----3.5-------The potential estimated probable risk
----3.6------Alternative Summary Table 
_4. The Selected Alternative 

 
Argument Overall Argument

4.0

______

The consistency and logic of the paper's argument and its adherence to the Flamholtz framework.

 

Presentation 
and 
Materials 		 2.0

 

______ 

 The quality of the presentation and its materials.
Subtotal


_________

  The score for the paper before taking penalties.
Penalties  
    -4.00

   __________ 		  Paper Order Specified in Spec not Followed.

    -2.00

    __________ 		 Paper Format Specified in Spec not Followed.
 
    -0.50

   __________ 		 Paper Length Specified in Spec not Followed.
    -1.00

    _______ 		 Fewer than 6 complete references
  -______
  @1.00  
    each 		 Number of incomplete references as defined in the specifications
Total  __________ a+  24.75  -  25.00
a 23.00 - 24.74
a- 22.50 - 22.99
b+  22.00 - 22.49
b 20.50 - 21.99 
b- 20.00 - 20.49
c+ 19.75 - 19.99
c 18.00 - 19.74
c- 17.50 -17.99 
f less than 17.50

                                         Last updated by Norma Sutcliffe on October 18, 2000 .