CHAPTER 6
MOTOR OUTPUT
- INTRODUCTION
- Levine identifies 4 motor pathways:
- Gross Motor - large muscles and/or whole body
- Fine Motor - muscles of hand and fingers
- Graphomotor - handwriting
- Oral Motor - speech muscles
- This chapter focuses on gross motor and graphomotor functions
- MOTOR ACTIONS
- An action is a controlled, organized movement
- Basic Concepts
- Motor idea - a specific plan of action for a very basic movement
- Motor proficiency - mastery of basic movements at automatic level
- Motor actions are guided by analysis of sensory data (visual, tactile, etc)
- Repeated motor experience enhances all aspects of processing
- Feedback from the senses enables us to continue, modify, or stop an action
- Motor engrams - stored patterns of familiar motor actions (movements
become automatic)
- Serial chaining - longer routines of stored sequences of motor movements
- Motor inhibition - allows us to smooth out an action by inhibiting
irrelevant or wasteful movements
- Motor plan (ideomotor plan)- a conscious or semi-conscious image of a
specific goal and a "blueprint" for accomplishing the action.
- Praxis - implementing the specific action or motor plan
- Automatized actions - actions that rely less heavily on conscious motor
plans and more on motor engrams
- Model of a Motor Action
- Perceiving a need for an action
- Selecting a particular action likely to meet the need, possibly requiring
intentional planning and problem-solving strategies
- Forming an image of what the action will look like
- Forming a motor idea - a preliminary notion of how the motor system
might respond
- Refining the motor idea into a highly specific ideomotor plan, with the
help of verbal instruction, spatial cues and/or memory of motor engrams
- Praxis - implementing the action itself.
- Quality-control - feedback provides information to adjust the movement
while in process
- Deciding whether the action is successful and should stop
- Action decays or is stored in motor memory
- FACTORS IN MOTOR DEVELOPMENT
- Gross Motor Development
- Increasing automaticity
- Increasing speed without sacrificing accuracy
- Increasing strength and stamina
- Increasing propulsion and acceleration when running
- Increasing ability to jump and throw (require both strength and
coordination)
- Increasing balance
- Increasing coordination
- Gender differences
- Boys excel in strength and gross movements
- Girls excel in fine coordination
- Fine Motor Development
- Increasing skill in eye-hand coordination
- Increasing automaticity and speed
- Increasing ability to use both hands together
- Increasing graphomotor ability
- Increasing motor inhibition in both fine and gross motor development
- GROSS MOTOR ABILITY: DEVELOPMENTAL VARIATION AND
DYSFUNCTION
- Gross Motor Ability
- Normal gross motor development has generally been described above
- Gross motor proficiency can contribute to self-image and sense of
competence
- Gross Motor Dysfunction
- Children with gross motor problems have significant difficulty with self-image and
social success
- Anomalies (neurological) of gross motor development associated with clumsiness:
- Mixed dominance or excessive right or left handedness
- The dominant hand does worse than the nondominant one
- Hand preference manifested too early or too late
- Persistent overflow movements
- Poor reciprocal alternation
- Difficulty imitating a sequence of movements
- Slow motor reaction time
- Difficulty with balance, body position sense, and proprioceptive
feedback
- Gross motor problems may have several underlying causes:
- Difficulty interpreting sensory information
- Lack of an ideomotor plan
- Difficulty invoking or coordinating specific motor actions
- Difficulty with motor memory or memory for a sequence of motor
actions
- Dyspraxia = difficulty accomplishing a motor action
- Dyspraxia may be inconsistent across actions or times
- Children with gross motor problems typically avoid athletics
- They may become scholars to compensate
- Avoidance and lack of practice widens the performance gap between typical and
"clumsy" children
- Some children avoid athletics not because of gross motor problems
but because of secondary attention or language problems
- Assessment of Gross Motor Functions can be accomplished by:
- Case history interview
- Observation of performance
- Observers must employ very careful task analysis
- Observers should compare easy and difficulty tasks
- Questionnaires
- Direct Assessment should include
- Eye-hand/arm coordination (catching a ball)
- Balance
- Body position sense
- Rapid alternating movements
- Rhythmic activities
- Differential diagnosis of clumsiness - can be caused by many medical
and/or neurological factors:
- Mild cerebral palsy
- Joint or nerve inflamation
- Hyperthyroidism
- Muscular dystrophy
- Congenital muscle disorders
- Hydrocephalus
- Brain tumor
- Spinal cord disorder
- Vision problems
- Vestibular (inner ear) problems
- Side effects of medications
- Psychological disorders
- Substance abuse
- Management of Gross Motor Dysfunction
- Types of intervention
- Remedial physical education
- Occupational therapy
- Physical Therapy
- Any management plan should identify and support relative strengths,
trying to find some motor sphere in which the child can succeed:
- individual vs. team sports
- activities that use inner spatial vs. outer spatial data
- Remedial physical education must ensure:
- privacy, avoiding humiliation
- adequate time for practice
- Management of Gross Motor Talents
- Balancing sports and academics is difficult if child has other learning
disabilities
- Academics can suffer even more because sports are a distraction
and a way to avoid studying
- But we can't deny athletics when it is a child's only source of self-esteem
- Often best to reduce athletics and substitute remedial help
- Managing gross motor talents requires:
- Sensitivity and understanding
- Close cooperation with parents and professionals
- Flexibility
- DEVELOPMENTAL OUTPUT FAILURE (FINE MOTOR
UNDERPINNINGS)
- Normal fine- and graphomotor development have generally been described above
- Developmental output failure (dysfunction) typically begins in the middle grades
when demands for output increase
- Evolving expectations for output in school include:
- Increased use of symbols
- Integration of information from multiple sources and various perspectives,
involves increased memory demands
- Increased sustained attention to detail
- Increased demand for rapid automatic retrieval of information
- Increased demand for retrieval of multiple, synchronized bits of
information
- Increased demand for large chunks of output
- Increased need for verbal fluency, sentence formulation, effective writing
- Intensified demand for speed, appropriate strategies, and organizational
skills
- Increased demand for automatic, efficient graphomotor skills for writing
- In summary, writing requires:
- Efficient coding of ideas
- Effective, fast, effortless memory
- Appropriate expressive language
- Synthesis and organization
- Sustained attention to detail
- Graphomotor proficiency
- Developmental output failure arises from a cluster of dysfunctions in b, c, d, e, and f
(above):
- Graphomotor Dysfunction - Four types of graphomotor dysfunction
hamper output and written fluency
- Impaired kinesthetic feedback
- When kinesthetic feedback is impaired children rely on
visual feedback and monitoring, and write with eyes close
to the page
- Using primarily visual feedback may work for nonverbal
activities such as sewing, building models, or fixing things
- Using primarily visual feedback for writing is too slow and
mechanical, so writing is slow, awkward, and lacks
automatization.
- Handwriting may be legible, but production is very slow,
lacks automaticity, and demands too much attention
- These children often have a distorted pencil grip because
they can't "perceive" the relationship of fingers to pencil
- These children often exert too much pressure on the pencil,
bearing down hard to get a better proprioceptive sense -
results in fatigue, cramps in the hand, broken pencil points,
torn paper, difficulty with ball point pens that are too
slippery
- Often the result is reduced quantity of writing
- Eye-hand coordination problems (poor visual perception and
feedback)
- These children are often poor at both nonverbal activities
and writing
- Child may have difficulty with writing off the side of the
paper, keeping margins straight, not staying on the lines,
downward or upward slant of a line, problems with
spacing, difficulty arranging columns in math. Letters may
be legible but poorly spaced.
- Dyspraxia (fine motor production problems) may result from:
- Difficulty forming a motor image (ideomotor plan) of the
required movement
- Difficulty actually implementing the plan motorically
(knowing what you want to do, but having difficulty
making the muscles do what you want them to)
- Writing is painfully slow and very awkward. Letter
formation may be jerky, wavy, bizarre. Child may seem to
laboriously "draw" each letter.
- Motor Memory Problems
- Child has difficulty retrieving the motor plan to form a
letter
- Lots of corrections, scratch outs, retracings, and erasures.
- Writing is often illegible, same letter formed different ways
and with minimal strokes.
- Child may never learn cursive because the demands on
motor memory is much greater, and probably should be
allowed to print.
- Retrieval Memory Problems
- When writing a child must retrieve letter formation, spelling,
grammar, punctuation, capitalization, scheme of ideas, vocabulary
etc.
- To be successful many of these must become automatic and
synchronized, leaving room for higher order thinking, planning,
etc.
- Children with retrieval problems can't synchronize all the things
needed at the same time to write efficiently
- Attention Problems
- Minimally motivating writing tasks may induce fatigue,
distraction, boredom, and impulsivity
- These children have difficulty monitoring, proofreading, attending
to the details of writing
- They have difficulty planning a composition because of poor
organization, previewing and synchronization.
- They may not meet the demands of the assignment either because
of poor monitoring, or because they didn't pay attention to the
assignment
- Language Problems
- Children with oral expressive language problems will also have
written expression problems
- They may have problems with:
- word-finding (vocabulary)
- syntax
- narrative organization
- metalinguistic awareness of what "sounds good"
- Organization Problems - children may have problems with:
- Spatial disorganization of materials - books, notebooks, pens,
worksheets. Items are forgotten, lost, left at home, etc.
- Temporal/sequential disorganization - difficulty allocating time
for tasks, late for class, sequencing steps in narratives, math
problems, or any long term assignment
- Difficulties with synthesizing and organizing ideas/data when
reading or writing
- Functional Profiles and Productivity
- Clusters of these 5 types of dysfunctions reduce output and
productivity
- A single dysfunction may not be especially problematic (e.g.
awkward pencil grasp) because most children can compensate and
are resilient
- When dysfunctions cluster together they may all be relatively mild
but still cause major problems because natural resiliency is
compromised
- Effects/Repercussions of Developmental Output Failure
- Children with developmental output failure are vulnerable to
depression, social maladjustment, underachievement because
impaired productivity in the middle grades can be a point of no
return academically
- If a lack of productivity in school is accompanied by poor results
in other areas (sports, music, etc) the result can be a profound
sense of inadequacy.
- Alternative Production Channels - Other areas in which children with
developmental output failure can find satisfaction and self-esteem
- Artistic endeavors
- Mechanical skills
- Nonathletic games (chess, computers)
- Crafts
- Music
- Collections (stamps, coins)
- Wage earning
- Pets, animals
- Special responsibilities
NOTE: Remedial strategies for developmental
output failure are discussed in Chapter 10
Writing and Spelling, and also in Chapter 15 Management Strategies