individual-assessment.html version 9.0

394/376 Elliott
Undergraduate projects class. Individual Assessment

Notes: Grading: Late papers, and electronic submissions, will not be accepted for credit. Please do not ask. Your work on themes one through four, along with YOUR ratings in the theme-four sections of your other group members' individual assessments, will be used in calculating your grade. Roughly 50 points of your exam will be determined by your other group members, but their comments might affect your grade beyond this if your documentation about your own contribution is not subtantial and they tend to be in agreement about your contribution. I reserve the right to give additional "group" credit, toward the assessment, to students that are very highly rated by their peers.


General instructions: Prepare a printed document of not more than three pages (excluding supporting materials such as time records), and not less than one page, addressing themes one to three, with your main focus on theme one. Put your name and GROUP NAME on the first page, with no cover page, and no binder materials. Then print, fill out, and turn in, the additional, separate, Cover Sheet for theme four, with your name, and your group name on it. Staple this IN FRONT of the other three sheets. Turn your (four-page or less) packet in, along with any supporting materials, at class, at the CTI front desk with instructions to place it in my mailbox, at a suburban campus with correct inter-office mail packaging, or via regular mail / FedEx. YOU ARE responsible that all regular mail / interoffice mail submissions really do reach me, and arrive by the required date, in my CTI mailbox.
Theme one (MAJOR component your exam): What did you do this quarter to help your project group succeed? Make your case. Be honest. Do not be bashful but also do not use hyperbole. Use facts, not opinion, whenever possible, to support your arguments. Give time, dates, and actions.

[Required supplement]: Provide a PRINTED daily record of your time for this class: what you did, when, and how long you spent. This cannot be handwritten, but otherwise can be very simple, and direct. (I am interested in information, not cosmetics!) However, consider that entries with just a label such as "wrote code" are not worth much as documentation. Minimal strong entries will have two or three sentences of detail about what you did on each occasion. Include ALL time you spent, and include total time. You can further break down your time totals into subcategories if you wish (thinking time, coding time, group meeting time, etc.). This printed log MUST be equivalent to that posted at the group web and have been reivewed by other group members after the "freeze" date. See the time-reporting example.

Theme two: What group-project principles would you apply if you were engaged to hire a project team, and complete a project of this type, in the real world? (Use outline form to list the principles, with discussion of the principle as needed). Examples of wins and failures in your own group are encouraged, but not required.

Hypothetical example entry for this theme:


"PRIOR PLANNING, and DYNAMIC PLANNING, are ESSENTIAL. I would devote
one senior-level salary to a person that could lay out a schedule for
the completion of the project, could dynamically modify it, and could
make everyone else in the group aware, daily, of what is on schedule,
what is slipping, and what else is affected. This would be a technical
person, skilled in planning, who did not have any personnel
responsibilities...[and so forth]" 
Theme three: Review the "frozen" time reporting pages at your group web site. List the group members, including yourself, alphabetically by last name (but include the full name of each member), and next to the name put down the total number of (substantiated) hours OF ALL KINDS spent by that group member. Total the number of hours. Feel free to cut and paste, into your text, from this template: group-time.html. (Note: every minute of class time spent working specifically on the project, every minute of group meetings, time spent on email, time spent thinking about aspects of the project on the train, etc., must be included for each member.) Comment on the time spent by each member. Is the reporting accurate?

Discuss the time spent compared with the product produced. Discuss whether or not time is wasted in groups over working alone, etc. Discuss "unofficial" time spent -- is this always required? Is there a cost for it? How did this amount of time compare with your projections? What advice will you give yourself about time projections in the future, if any?

All of the group time logs are posted. Are there any that you feel are inflated, or under-reported? Each group member should briefly discuss their hours with the group. Groups should dedicate at least a few minutes for this exercise near the "freeze" date. Bring your log to the meeting!

Theme four: Use the group rating sheet to provide your numerical assessment of the contributions of all group members. Your ability to assess your group, and group members, is a required skill, and is counted as part of your exam.

Staple this on the TOP of your four-page-or-less individual assessment.



Street mail address:

Professor Clark Elliott
CTI
DePaul University
243 South Wabash Ave.
Chicago, IL 60604	  


DePaul Interoffice Mail address:

Professor Clark Elliott
CTI