1.4

CSC208 Structured Outline Feedback Form

Staple this to the front of your structured outline.

[                      ]

[                                   ]

(Enter your four-character code, and group color, above)

  Clarity Points 0-5     Content Points 0-5          Clarity       Contents            Clarity        Contents            Clarity        Contents   
A. H. O. V.
B. I. P. W.
C. J. Q. X.
D. K. R. Y.
E. L. S. Z.
F. M. T. AA.
G. N. U. BB.
Avg Avg     Avg Avg     Avg Avg     Avg Avg
.
Structure Rank     Structure Rank     Structure Rank     Structure Rank
.
Content Rank     Content Rank     Content Rank     Content Rank
.
Overall Rank     Overall Rank     Overall Rank     Overall Rank

Key

  1. There is room for up to four groups to review this structured outline (S/O).
  2. Pick a letter A—G, H—N, etc. as your anonymous reviewer name within the group.
  3. Points are assigned from 0 to 5 with 0=No Value and 5=Maximum Value.
  4. Assign both clarity points and content points for this S/O in the two cells in the row next to your letter.
  5. After all group members have given points for clarity and contents, write down the average values at the bottom of the column.
  6. Rankings are from 1 to N, where N is the number of papers you have reviewed in this round. N=Top Ranking, 1=Bottom Ranking.
  7. No ties allowed.
  8. Use the form x/N for rankings. E.g. for a set of 5 papers 5/5 would be the top ranking and 1/5 would be the lowest.
  9. Discuss all the papers in this reviewing round.
  10. Assign rankings for clarity, content, and overall for each paper.
  11. Write the three rankings down for each paper.