DePaul University
School for New Learning
College Writing on the Web
Writing Topics
Modified March 10, 1997
This is a 7 page document and includes forms which might be useful for
paper #2. Feel free to print it.
Paper #1
for this course will be a
description of a 30 minute television news broadcast and an
analysis/evaluation of that broadcast. This should not be a newsy program
such as "20/20" or "60 Minutes" or one of the Sunday morning talk shows. We're looking for the
news broadcasts with anchors
like Tom Brokaw or Dan Rather or the local version of the same.
The first step in writing this paper will be to take notes on a 30 minute
local news broadcast (excluding the sports and weather segments) and a 30
minute national news broadcast. Video taping these broadcasts usually
makes this paper much easier to write. After watching and taking notes on these broadcasts,
choose either
program for this paper. The final paper should describe the contents of
the broadcast and you should evaluate the program. Did this broadcast
cover the
most important local/national issues of the day? Why or why not? Do you think television news
is a valuable,
reliable source for learning about the world/your community? Why or why
not? Answering these final questions - evaluating TV news - is a very
important part of this assignment.
After watching a news broadcast and
taking notes, it might
be worthwhile to send an email note to classmates and share a few of your
preliminary thoughts about writing this paper. And feel free to send any
questions or observations or difficulties or problems. If someone else is writing on the same
broadcast, it would be interesting to compare preliminary notes, observations, and analyses.
Miscellaneous points to consider when writing this paper
- How much detail is needed for each news story? Enough for the reader to understand both
what was reported and also your analysis of the story. How much is enough? How much is too
much? I would suggest limiting the description of
each story to 2-3 sentences.
- I suggest you use a traditional introduction to identify the background (time, place, station
identification, and date) of the news broadcast and something about your analysis or evaluation.
The introduction can also contain a sentence or two to introduce an important point or theme
from your analysis. You might want to introduce yourself in the intro - a couple sentences (but
no more than this) so the readers know if you watch TV all the time, or never watch the news, or
prefer certain newspaper or TV stations or radio stations. (See number 3).
- Do you regularly watch TV news? Why or why not? This is probably worth putting in the
paper so your readers can understand something about your general perspective on TV news. Do
you get news from other sources? Do you think the program you watched covered the most
important events of the day? Why? Someone, somewhere actually decides what is broadcast
every night. On what basis do you think "they" decide what gets broadcast? Do you think there
is much difference between various local and national news broadcast? If they are similar, how
can this be explained? Conspiracy??? If they are different, then how can the differences be
explained?
- Here is just an observation, and not necessarily a suggestion: Some people choose (perhaps
unconsciously) to focus on the content of the news broadcast without mentioning the news
anchors or local reporters. Other papers mention the content of a news broadcast, but also focus
on the race, age, sex, and appearance of the
broadcasters and as well as the people covered or quoted in different
stories. Those papers are interesting because they raised issues that
some people might take for granted. Writing any paper involves choosing between many
different options, but often
our choices are made unconsciously, without considering alternatives. The
more a writer is aware of different angles, perspectives, organizational
strategies, etc. then choices about writing become more conscious.
- You don't
have to
present the news reports chronologically. You could present them
according to theme. For example, one thematic paragraph could discuss the
news reports on governmental decisions; another paragraph could discuss
the electoral news; another paragraph might report on international issues;
perhaps there could be a paragraph on crime-related stories. After the
news reports are organized into themes, then your analysis can also be
organized into similar themes. For example, you can analyze each theme in a separate
paragraph. This
might provide some better overall organization to your
paper.
- How about discussing the graphics that accompany each story?
After all, the biggest difference between TV and radio news (maybe) is the
pictures, so are the pictures worth describing? Does a story become more
"newsworthy" when it is accompanied by photos? Even TV news stories which don't have any
photos always seem to get accompanied by graphics, even when the graphics are seemingly
unnecessary or irrelevant.
Not all these questions can be answered in every paper, but the questions are worth considering.
This paper will probably need at least 3 pages, about 1000 words.
Paper #2 for this course will be based on a survey
you conduct of friends, neighbors, co-workers, fellow students, strangers. In this survey you'll
ask 30 people a question which can be answered yes/no/maybe/I-don't-know and record their
results. I'll provide a list of possible questions to
ask, but feel free to think of others, as long as you run the question by
me before starting the survey.
The written paper on this topic
will include these sections: The reason you chose that survey question;
your predictions and expected answers according to the age, sex,
ethnicity, religion, etc. of the respondents; a description of finding
people to survey; a description of the surveys answers focused on patterns according to
demographics, if any occur; some thoughts on unexpected results or surprises; some thoughts on
things you would change to make this survey more effective; some conclusions about the
experience. This paper will probably require about 5 pages, some 1400 words. There will be
more on this paper later in the quarter.
Preparation for paper #2
For this paper, each student will choose one yes/no question, such as "Do you think marijuana
should be legalized?", or "Do you think the drinking age should be lowered to 18?", or "Do you
think the age for getting a driver's license should be raised to 19?" You can choose a question
from the list below, or you can make up your own question. Please let me know which question
you've chosen before you start your survey. I think it's best to survey 30 people - 15 men and
15 women.
After you've chosen your question, you can begin writing your paper. Write a paragraph to
explain why you chose this question, and why you think this will be an interesting question to
ask. Write another paragraph or two to predict the results for this survey. For example, predict
if men will answer this question differently than women; predict if older people will answer
differently from younger; predict if answers will correspond to ethnicity or race; predict if
married people will have different answers than single and divorced people; make any
predictions that might correspond to physical appearance or marital status or anything else. Or
you can combine your predictions and say something like, "I expect older white men to be
against legalizing marijuana, while most older women and almost all younger people will be in
favor of
it." I'm obviously making up these examples, but when you find a question that interests you,
then spend a little time trying to decide how different groups of people might answer this
question. Your predictions should be based on the people you are expecting to survey. If you
aren't planning to interview any Spanish-speakers, then don't predict how Spanish speakers will
answer this question. If you aren't planning to survey any young people, then don't make any
predictions for young people's answers.
The next step is to conduct the survey. There are forms below to help you compile your
results.
As you conduct the survey, you should note each person's answer on the form. The name does
not need to be the full name, just something so you can keep track of the people you've talked to.
After the survey is completed, add up the totals and fill in the appropriate categories in the
second form. You are looking for patterns according to age, ethnicity, sex, marital status,
occupation, etc. If there are patterns, such as all (or even the majority) women saying yes, or all
older people saying
no, or all married people saying maybe, then that is interesting and should be reported. Will
there be such patterns? I don't know, but that's one of the things to look for.
When you report the results of your survey, you'll want to report the raw numbers - the total
number of YES, NO, MAYBE, and I DON'T KNOW. In addition, you'll want to report any
patterns you have discovered.
In the section of your paper before the report on the results of your survey, there should be
several sentences to explain the methodology of your survey. For example, you should explain
where you found people to survey. In the office or factory or studio? In the streets? On
campuses and cafeterias and coffee shops? Did you ask only people you knew? Did you ask
family members or friends or old lovers or ministers or rabbis or monks or people on the bus?
Just tell us how you went about asking people this question.
After writing up the results of your survey, tell us about anything interesting or new you
learned.
This can be anything you discovered as a result of doing this survey. Maybe you discovered that
doing surveys was a lot of fun. Maybe you discovered that men hated to be surveyed and women
loved it, or visa versa. Who knows what you'll discover here?
In the final paper to write up this survey, don't forget to include a section on whether or not
your
predictions were fulfilled. Did you get the responses you had predicted? If not, why not?
Finally, in your conclusion write something about the validity of your survey. Was this a
valid,
accurate cross-section of the American population, or of the Chicago population, or of any other
population. If you did this survey again (don't worry - you don't have to) what would you do
differently?
An outline of the survey might look something like this:
1. Introduction - My question and the reasons I chose it
2. My predictions
3. My system for finding people to survey
4. An analysis of the results of that survey and a comparison to my predictions
5. Things I learned from this survey
6. Conclusion - validity, things to do differently, etc.
There are other ways to organize your final paper, and the most important thing is to include
all
these sections in whatever order seems effective to you.
|
Name |
Answer |
Age |
Ethnic
Group |
Marital
Status |
Sex |
| 1 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 2 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 3 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 4 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 5 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 6 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 7 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 8 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 9 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 10 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 11 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 12 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 13 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
.
| 14 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| 15 |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
. |
You can change the categories above and below however you like.
|
Yes |
No |
Don't
know |
Maybe |
| Total |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Females |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Males |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Older females
(define) |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Younger fmales
(define) |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Older males |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Younger males |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Ethnic group |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Ethnic group |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Ethnic group |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Other |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Other |
. |
. |
. |
. |
| Other |
. |
. |
. |
. |
Questions for Surveys
- Do you believe that teachers in elementary school should be allowed to use corporal
punishment?
- Do you think the death penalty deters crime or lowers the crime rate?
- Do you believe that women should have the same rights to work and get an education
that men have?
- Do you think there is too much prejudice against minorities in the USA?
- Do you believe that people should only marry someone of the same race and ethnic
background?
- If parents do not approve of a child's boyfriend or girlfriend, should the child break up
with the boyfriend or girlfriend?
- Should college be free for every person who wants to attend?
- Do you think it's OK for a 17 year old girl to get married?
- Do you think it's OK for a 17 year old guy to get married?
- Should students get paid for going to school?
- Should students work while they are attending college?
- Do you think that watching television affects the way people act and think?
- Should the age for getting a drivers' license be raised to 18?
- Should the age for drinking alcohol be lowered to 18?
- Is it OK for a 19 year old to have a beer or two to relax?
- Should smoking marijuana be legalized so people don't go to jail for it?
- Does television make children and adults more violent?
- Do you think it's OK for a man and woman to live together before getting married?
- Should the relatives of immigrants in the USA be allowed to move to this country?
Paper #3 for this course will be based on articles or
columns you read from newspapers, magazines, journals, or other sources available on the
Internet. For this paper you will need to briefly summarize two different sources on any
social/political issue or event you find interesting and explain your own opinion on that topic.
You will need to cite your sources according to MLA or APA guidelines, and the textbook for
this course describes how to do this. This paper should be at least 3 pages, around 1000 words.
The assignment has two parts: first, to summarize and compare what 2 different writers
have to say about a current social issue or event; second, to explain your own opinion and
analysis
of that issue or event. Let's take the first part first:
The sources for this paper should be 2 reputable, high quality
articles from two different Internet
periodicals or reference sources. Please send me the URLs
for your articles BEFORE you start writing this paper.
The purpose of this
part of the assignment is developing your ability to accurately summarize outside sources
because
students spend considerable time summarizing articles and books and then interpreting and
evaluating those articles and books. This assignment should get you in the mood for the courses
to follow. (Smile. This will be fun.) If you already know how to summarize sources and use
either APA or MLA to cite those sources, then this will be a snap. If you don't know how, this is
where you'll learn. "Summarize" means tell us the main idea of each article without using more
than a sentence or two of direct quotations. You'll probably need a paragraph or so to summarize
the most important parts of each article.
The second part of the assignment is to give us your
informed opinion
on the issue/event
and the way it was reported. How did the reports differ and why? Why is
this event/issue important?
What does it mean? And then you'll explain and defend your analysis of
the issue/event. Explaining
your opinion means taking several paragraphs to explain what you believe and why you believe
it
and then providing examples and evidence to support your belief and
convince us that you know
what you're talking about.
How to begin? Ahh, there are at least 2 ways to start - one is looking through a list of
contemporary events/issues and finding relevant articles from newspapers and other sources.
Click here to look at Yahoo's list of current
events and issues. Once you get there you can look at current events or you can scroll down to
the list of newspapers and publications and read newspapers before you pick a current event or
issue.
Another way to find articles about current issues is to look at the Reference Page for this
course.
You could look at The Media Watchdog or any of the
"Sites which discuss and argue..." Whether you go through Yahoo! or the Reference Page, or use
any other search method,
there will be no shortage of articles and opinions on any social/political issue.
Don't wait too long before looking for articles! There are
tens of thousands of articles out there and it's easy to get lost and bewildered and overwhelmed.
Spending 30 minutes looking 4-6 times for suitable articles is better than waiting until too late
and
spending 3 hours in front of the screen. If you keep a notebook handy and record the articles,
periodicals, and Web sites that are and are NOT worth revisiting , you can save yourself a lot of
time. You can also print articles for future reference.
Finally, explaining your own opinion and analysis isn't always so easy. Here is an excellent
place (The Roane State Community
College Online Writing Lab) to find information on writing a persuasive paper. Look under
Argumentation and Argumentative Essays. The link is slow at times, but worth the wait. There
is
plenty of helpful information here about writing academic papers.
Please remember to email me the URL of any sources you want to use in Paper #3.
First timers - I suggest New stuff next.
After that, you're on your own. If you have any
questions about anything in this course, please
contact
me at dsorsa@condor.depaul.edu